Monday, May 25, 2015

Phillies 100 Years Ago: Alexander Pitches Gem to Bring Phillies Back to First Place

May 25, 1915

Phillies vs. Chicago Cubs
Athletics @ Cleveland Indians

We are back after a substantial break in the action.  The Phillies were rained out or had the day off for four straight days.  The Athletics beat the Tigers on May 21st to momentarily escaped from last place, but then lost the next two to reclaim the basement slot.  Today they beat the Indians for the second day in a row, but this was still not enough to pull them up to seventh place.  In fact, they had been in last place for four days in a row, which, as we talked about in an earlier post, were more days in last place than in their entire existence before 1915.  

As for new from around the world, Italy finally officially joined the war on May 23rd with their declaration against Austria-Hungary.  Two days into the fighting and the Italians were already proving to be a pest in the side of the Central Powers when they drove the Austria-Hungarian forces out through Tyrol Pass and were poised to take the city of Trent within the next couple of days.  Today also marked the official end to the Second Battle of Ypres.  You know, the Battle of Ypres that we talked about a month ago as the first time poison gas was used by the Germans and how warfare was changed forever?  Yeah, that battle has been going on almost non-stop since then.  During this month both sides accounted for more than 100,000 casualties just in this section of the Western Front line around Ypres; over 100,000 men dead, wounded, or missing in a month that doesn’t even take into consideration the Russians and Germans battling in the east, the fighting in the Balkans, or the Italians or Ottoman sections of the war.  It’s the equivalent of full Beaver Stadium being gassed, bombarded, starved, machine gunned, and tortured for an entire month.  It’s a kind of destruction whose scale is hard to even imagine or appreciate reading about it in a blog 100 years later.  But as this is a baseball blog, we have to make one of those hard right-turn transitions away from war and back to baseball.

The Phillies’ time off was actually detrimental to their position in the standings.  The Cubs beat the Braves on May 21st to tie the Phillies for first place, and when they won in Boston again the next day the top spot in the National League belonged to Chicago.  The Phillies were at the trough of their season while the Cubs were cresting; Chicago was 15-6 since April 27th whereas the Phillies went 7-10.  Roger Bresnahan, manager for Chicago, had bragged to beat writers that he though his club would win the National League for sure if he could just get his pitchers to throw at the highest level they were capable of.  Well, in May Bresnahan got what he wanted from the bump and proved his baseball acumen.

Bert Humphries took the hill today at the Baker Bowl to face off against Grover Cleveland Alexander.  Alex, as you may recall, pitched in the Phillies last game and took a bad loss.  Today he would have to outpitch a hot Humphries, who had yet to allow a run so far this season.  Bert was mostly a relief pitcher, but he did have one start this year against the Giants where he shut them out after only allowing five hits all game.  Batters had just a .343 OPS off of him this season, making the task for the Phillies to break out of their most recent hitting slump seem all the more daunting.  Even Fred Luderus’ return to the lineup today could not refute the fact that today’s game was going to be a pitching duel.  It looked like it was going to have to be Alexander that kept his team in the game until they could hopefully squeeze a run or two past this great Cubs team.  Even this was no easy task as Alexander struggled to beat the Cubs more than any other team on the circuit throughout his career for one reason or another.

The game certainly lived up to the billing.  Through five innings neither squad could get much accomplished off of these great pitchers.  In the second inning Henie Zimmerman, a heel to the fans in Philadelphia, reached base on an error.  He made his way to third base, but got cocky with his lead.  Bill Killefer fired a pick off throw up the line to Bobby Byrne, who put a great tag on Zimmerman, resulting in an out and an end to the rally.  Zimmerman, who was known as a hothead that relished in arguing with umpires, calmly marched back to the dugout despite the close play.  He knew his role in this game was important and to get himself tossed so early in the match would kill his team’s momentum.  Phillies’ left fielder Beals Becker was not so smart about his decisions when he was booted from the game for arguing a similar play with the umpire.  This goes to show the mind set both teams were in for today’s game.  The Cubs had been winning so much that a mental mistake was nothing they couldn’t overcome, but the Phillies were in a place where every mistake seemed like another Everest to climb over.  The tension was only increasing as the innings were marked off on the scoreboard with zero after zero.

The bottom of the sixth proved to be the decisive frame.  Byrne’s single was followed by a double from Becker to put runners at second and third.  Gavvy Cravath came and smashed what looked like a ball in the gap off the bat, but it was run down and caught for an out.  Byrne scored and Becker took third on the sacrifice fly.  Later in the inning Cubs’ shortstop Bob Fisher made his 13th throwing error of the season allowing Becker to stride home.  From here out it was Alexander’s game.  He dominated the batters in the seventh for a much needed shutdown inning and then drove in a run of his own in bottom half of the inning.  Chicago was held hitless for the remainder of game and Alexander redeemed himself for his previous bad outing.[1]

The win put the Phillies back into a tied for first place.  Alexander had his best game of the season, notching his second shutout and ninth complete game in ten starts.  His record bumped to 8-2 while his ERA dropped to 1.31.  The bats didn’t come back to life today, but they did just enough to get the job done.  It was a very exciting game and a hard fought victory for the Phillies.  The schedule had the squads facing off again tomorrow, but once again Mother Nature had the last say, so the rubber match for first place was held on May 27th, which is where we will pick up the story next time.   



[1] “Quality of Cubs Pitching Assures Look-In For Pennant,” Evening Ledger, May 26, 1915, accessed May 25, 2015, http://1.usa.gov/1ceAbGg.

No comments:

Post a Comment