Monday, July 6, 2015

Phillies 100 Years Ago: Phillies Barely Show Up, Lose 5-1 To New York

July 6, 1915

Phillies vs. New York Giants
Athletics @ New York Yankees

Last night the Liberty Bell made a stop in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania on its way to the west coast.  The Harrisburg Telegraph said that 15,000 people attended the showing.  A large parade was held, replete with representatives of the National Guard and the Daughters of the American Revolution, that went from Elizabethtown up to Second and Vine Streets in the state’s capital.  All along the route people threw jewelry and coins up on the car carrying the bell hoping they would be rubbed on the relic for luck.  Thousands of children were afforded the opportunity to kiss the bell as it went by, including the 6-year old John Bevan Pearson, the youngest descendent of the city’s founder John Harris.  The event was called “one of the most successful municipal celebrations ever held in this city.”  It was Liberty Bell mania!  But, sadly, all crazes over national symbols of freedom must come to an end and the residents of Harrisburg bid the bell farewell as it departed for Pittsburgh at 7:30 last night.  There were fears in Philadelphia that the jaunt would permanently damage the bell’s already fragile form, but so far they were unfounded and its presence provided a surge of pride for the nation amongst citizens that otherwise would not get the privilege to view it at Independence Hall.[1]

The Seattle Star had a front page for the ages today that gave a glimpse into life in 1915.  There was a rash of tuberculosis from drinking milk that caused debate about who should monitor bacteria in cow’s milk.  A new bill passed that mandated a tuberculin test be administered before the milk is sold to the public, but a heated battle was being fought over whether a government agent or the individual dairy farmers should clear the milk for consumption.  Also, a bill that would allow dancing in hotels and cafes was postponed.  The law, as of printing, allowed for dancing only in rooms that did not house the main bar of an institution.  All dancing in bars was strictly prohibited.  In a similar vein of strange entertainment ordinances, player pianos were banned from performing in front of movie theaters, but don’t worry all you lovers of self-playing musical instruments, there was an official protest lodged in hopes of overturning this one.  In national news, the people on Seattle were concerned with public hangings that were to take place in Mississippi.  Apparently they believed that holding “public picnics” while “thousands gather to see 5 men enter eternity” was crass.  The celebrations at a previous hanging had one citizen proclaim, “You would have though the towns were holding a county fair or street carnival instead of hangings.  People came from every direction.  From Laurel, Miss., a dozen miles or so from Bay Springs, an excursion train was run.  It carried nearly 1,000 people.”  These days we think of public hangings as something from the far distance past or, at the very least, performed by extralegal lynch mobs, but even 100 years ago Americans gathered around the gallows as a form of entertainment in some sections of the country.  Finally, there was news about Frank Holt, the man that attempted to kill JP Morgan and his family (or, if you take his account, just scare them a little with weapons of war).  Firstly, it appears he was not the man that poisoned his wife while at Harvard, so we needn’t worry about that anymore.  But, sadly for him, he did try to slit his wrists with a jagged piece of tin while cooped up in his jail cell last night, so it wasn’t his greatest day.[2]

In “Baseball Is Dying, You Guys” news that would be published on Hardball Talk if it was written today, apparently the people’s excitement about baseball was going the way of the buffalo.  An author that only went by the name “Girard” proclaimed in the Public Ledger that attendance was down because baseball was no longer the national pastime and will be dead within a few years.  A counterpoint in the Evening Ledger made the argument that maybe, just maybe, Girard was a fool.  See, Girard was in attendance for many Athletics games at Shibe Park this season and notice that there weren’t as many people in the stands as there was last year and the only possible reason for this was that 1 + 1 = 3 and ohmygod baseball is dying.  It couldn’t be that in the Athletics he witnessed an outlier club or that teams that are 18 games below .500 tend to barely draw at all.  No, baseball is dying.  But, back in reality where facts are necessary to base arguments, attendance was actually up among professional baseball games, and that did not even take into account the thousands of independent teams that operated successfully all over the nation.  Hell, if Girard walked the few blocks east of Shibe Park to the Baker Bowl he would see the Phillies drawing better than they had in 33 years!

The first two games of the Phillies series with the Giants drew 22,000 fans, by far the largest draw for games played on Monday and Tuesday (the next highest was 11,000), so obvious there was at least one team in Philadelphia able to attract patrons.  The 6,000 that showed up for today’s game, however, left disappointed; the Phillies were not able to capitalize on the momentum built from Grover Cleveland Alexander’s near no-hitter the previous day.  They didn’t even make it out of the first inning before they were down and out.  Erskine Mayer, the starter for Philadelphia, was anything but the solid ace he proved to be all season when he allowed four Giants to cross home before he got the second out of the first inning.  After another run came across for New York in the third, manager Pat Moran had enough.  Mayer left giving up five runs on seven hits in just three innings of work, by far the poorest start for him on the year. 

Mayer’s teammates seemingly decided that if the contest was blown out so early, they didn’t have to keep their heads in the game.  The Phillies banged 12 hits on Giants starter Rube Marquard, but dumb base-running errors held the club’s run total to one.  There were guys thrown out trying to take an extra base on balls hit right to the outfielders and guys that were picked off because they weren’t paying close attention to the pitcher all day long.  Just unacceptable play after unacceptable play.  If Gavvy Cravath didn’t blast his 12th home run of the year, it would have been a 12-hit shutout for Marquard.  As was the case, they did get a single run, but it was probably the worst game the club played all year; the 5-1 score didn’t do the embarrassing display justice. [3] 

But, as the old cliché goes, the best thing about baseball is that there is always a tomorrow.  Today’s tomorrow held a doubleheader for the Phillies and Giants, and with it a chance to reclaim some ground lost to the Cubs.  It was also a chance for Mayer to regain his form because Moran tapped him to start the first game.  I guess he figured Mayer didn’t really exert himself too much by allowing the Giants to trounce him in three innings.  It’s a strange move that would never be made by a manager today, but maybe Moran was onto something.  Maybe Mayer would pitch with a chip on his shoulder that would set his team on the winning path and, with a little luck, draw them to within only 0.5 games of Chicago.  This hanging out first place without ever taking it was getting old.  It was time for some action!



[1] “Liberty Bell Kissed By Boys And Girls As They Pass Relic,” Harrisburg Telegraph, July 6, 1915, accessed July 6, 2015, http://1.usa.gov/1J0tX6k.
[2] Seattle Star, July 6, 1915, accessed July 6, 2015, http://1.usa.gov/1eyjZRP.
[3] “Increasing Attendance Proves Baseball Still ‘National Pastime,’” Evening Ledger, July 7, 1915, accessed July 6, 2015, http://1.usa.gov/1G32Y81.

No comments:

Post a Comment